| Title (Release Year) | Co-Author(s) | Performers | Issue |
|---|
![]() |
When You and I Were Young Maggie (1911) | Frank Coombs | Indestructible Record: 3199 |
| Title | Co-Author(s) | Sequencer |
|---|
![]() |
Maggie's Answer (1868) | Benjamin R. Tubb | |
![]() |
When You and I Were Young Maggie (1866) | Unknown |
| Title (Release Year) | Composer | Performers | Issue |
|---|
![]() |
When You and I Were Young Maggie (1915) | J.A. Butterfield | W.V. Brunt Mary Carson Donald Alexander Chalmers Elizabeth Spencer John Young |
Edison: 4277 |
![]() |
When You and I Were Young Maggie (1917) | J.A. Butterfield | Ruby Helder | Columbia: 47455 |
| Title | Attribution | Remarks |
|---|
| When You and I Were Young Maggie | J.A. Butterfield (music) George W. Johnson (words) Harry MacDonough (perf.) |
| Title | Attribution | Instruments | Source | Remarks |
|---|
![]() |
Maggie's Answer (1868) | J.A. Butterfield (w&m) | Piano, Voice | Sheet Music Singer | |
![]() |
When You and I Were Young Maggie (1866) | J.A. Butterfield (music) George W. Johnson (words) |
Piano, Voice | Sheet Music Singer | |
![]() ![]() |
When You and I Were Young, Maggie (1866) | J.A. Butterfield (music) George W. Johnson (words) |
Piano, Voice | Greer Indiana |
Pub. |
(w&m)
| Title | Year | Attribution | Remarks |
|---|
| When You and I Were Young Maggie | 1866 | George W. Johnson (words) Gus Arnheim (perf.) Walter Van Brunt (perf.) Mary Carson (perf.) Donald Alexander Chalmers (perf.) Frank Coombs (perf.) Ruby Helder (perf.) Harry MacDonough (perf.) Elizabeth Spencer (perf.) John Young (perf.) |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
| Maggie's Answer (w&m) | 1868 | |